Two Narratives of Creation

network 4109223 1920

The Torah describes two acts of creation: God's creation of the universe, and the Israelites' creation of the mikdash or Mishkan, the sanctuary that travelled with them in the desert, the prototype of the Temple in Jerusalem.

The connection between them is not incidental. As a number of commentators have noted, the Torah invokes a series of verbal parallels between them. The effect is unmistakable. The latter mirrors the former. As God made the universe so He instructed the Israelites to make the Mishkan. It is their first great constructive and collaborative act after crossing the Red Sea, leaving the domain of Egypt and entering their new domain as the people of God. Just as the universe began with an act of creation, so Jewish history (the history of a redeemed people) begins with an act of creation:

"And you shall sanctify it and all its vessels"

Shemot 40:9
The universe (Bereishit)The Mishkan (Shemot)
“And God made the sky”“They shall make Me a Sanctuary”
“And God made the two large lights”“They shall make an Ark”
“And God made the beasts of the earth” (Bereishit 1:7, 1:16, 1:25)“Make a table” (Shemot 25:8, 9, 23)
“And God saw all that He had made, and behold it was very good.” (Bereishit 1:31)“Moses saw all the skilled work and behold they had done it; as God commanded it, they had done it.” (Shemot 39:43)
“The heavens and earth and all of their array were completed.” (Bereishit 2:1)“All the work of the Tabernacle of the Tent of Meeting was completed” (Shemot 39:32)
“And God completed all the work that He had done” (Bereishit 2:2)“And Moses completed the work” (Shemot 40:33)
“And God blessed” (Bereishit 2:3)“And Moses blessed” (Shemot 39:43)
“And sanctified it” (Bereishit 2:3)“And you shall sanctify it and all its vessels" (Shemot 40:9)

The key words - make, see, complete, bless, sanctify, work, behold - are the same in both narratives. The effect is to suggest that making the Mishkan was, for the Israelites, what creating the universe was for God.

Yet the disparity is extraordinary. The creation of the universe takes a mere 34 verses (Bereishit ch. 1 together with the first three verses of Bereishit ch. 2). The making of the Mishkan takes hundreds of verses (Terumah, Tetzaveh, part of Ki Tissa, Vayakhel and Pekudei) - considerably more than ten times as long. Why? The universe is vast. The sanctuary was small, a modest construction of poles and drapes that could be dismantled and carried from place to place as the Israelites journeyed through the wilderness. Given that the length of any passage in the Torah is a guide to the significance it attaches to an episode or law, why devote so much time and space to the Tabernacle? The answer is profound. The Torah is not man's book of God. It is God's book of mankind. It is not difficult for an infinite, omnipotent creator to make a home for humanity. What is difficult is for human beings, in their finitude and vulnerability, to make a home for God. Yet that is the purpose, not only of the Mishkan in particular but of the Torah as a whole.

A Midrash puts it graphically:

"It came to pass on the day that Moses finished erecting the Tabernacle" [Num. 7:1] - Rabbi [Judah HaNasi] said, "Wherever it says 'and it came to pass' it refers to something new." Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai said, "Wherever it says 'and it came to pass' it refers to something that existed in the past, and was then interrupted, and then returned to its original situation."

This is the meaning of the words "I have come into My garden, My sister, My bride" (Song of Songs 5:1). When the Holy One, blessed be he, created the universe, he desired to have a dwelling place in the lower worlds, as he has in the upper worlds. He summoned Adam and said, "You are free to eat from any tree in the garden; but you must not eat from the tree of knowledge of good and evil" but Adam transgressed the command. The Holy One, blessed be He, said to him: "This is what I wanted, that just as I have a dwelling place in the upper worlds, so I wished to have a dwelling place in the lower worlds. I commanded you one thing, and you did not keep it!" Immediately, God withdrew His Presence to the heavens . . .

[The Midrash then lists the subsequent sins of humankind, each of which caused the Divine Presence to withdraw one more level from the earth. Then came Abraham and his descendants, each of whom brought the Divine Presence one stage closer...]

Then came Moses and brought the Divine Presence down to earth. When? When the Tabernacle was erected. Then the Holy One, blessed be He, said: "I have come into my garden, My sister, My bride" - I have come to that which I desired [from the outset]. This is the meaning of "It came to pass on the day that Moses finished erecting the Tabernacle" - the source of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai's statement that "Wherever it says 'and it came to pass' it refers to something that existed in the past, and was then interrupted, and then returned to its original situation."

Tanchumah [Buber], Naso, 24

The Tabernacle, small and fragile though it was, was an event of cosmic significance. It brought the Divine Presence [Shechinah, which comes from the same root as Mishkan] down from heaven to earth. How, though, are we to understand this idea? It is contained in one of the key words of the Torah, namely kadosh, "holy".

As the Jewish mystics noted, creation involves an act of self-limitation on the part of the Creator. The word olam, "universe" is directly related to the word ne-elam, meaning "hidden". For there to be the possibility of a being with freewill, choice and moral responsibility, God cannot be a ubiquitously tangible presence. When the Israelites heard the voice of God at Sinai, they said to Moses, "Speak to us yourself and we will listen. But do not have God speak to us or we will die" (Ex. 20:19). The direct, unmediated presence of God is overwhelming.

The infinite crowds out the finite. God is like a parent; and unless a parent lets go, the child will never learn to walk. Letting go means that the child will stumble and fall, but not for ever. Eventually it will learn to walk. So it is with other forms of learning-by-doing. At various stages a parent must progressively withdraw to leave space for the child to grow. So too God must withdraw if humanity - made in His image - is eventually to become His "partner in the work of creation". Creation is an act of Divine self-limitation.

This, however, creates a paradox. If God is perceptible everywhere, there is no room for humankind. But if God is perceptible nowhere, how can humanity know Him, reach Him, or understand what He wants from us? The answer - already hinted at in the account of creation itself - is that God reserves, in several dimensions, a domain that is peculiarly His. The first is in time - the seventh day (and eventually, the seventh month, the seventh year, and the jubilee at the end of the seventh cycle of sabbatical years). The second was among the nations after their division into multiple languages and civilisations - the covenantal people, the children of Israel. The third was in space - the Tabernacle. Each of these is holy, meaning, a point at which the Divine Presence emerges from hiddenness to exposure, from concealment to revelation. As Shabbat is to time, so the Tabernacle was to space: kadosh, holy, set apart, God's domain. The holy is the metaphysical arena where heaven and earth meet.

That meeting has specific parameters. It is where God rules, not humankind. Therefore it is associated with the renunciation of the autonomous human will. There is no room for private initiative on the part of humankind. That is why later, Nadav and Avihu die because they bring a fire-offering that "was not commanded." Just as chol ("the secular") is where God practises self-limitation to create space for mankind, so kodesh is where human beings engage in self-limitation to create space for God.

That is why the creation of the Tabernacle by the Israelites is the counterpart of the creation of the universe by God. Both were acts of self-renunciation whereby the one made space for the other. The elaborate detail with which the Torah describes the making of the Mishkan is to show that none of it was done at the initiative of Moses, or Betzalel, or the Israelites themselves. Hence the lack of parallelism at one crucial point. Whereas after the creation of the universe we read, "And God saw all that He had made, and behold it was very good" (Bereishit 1:31), after the making of the Mishkan we read, "Moses saw all the skilled work and behold they had done it; as God commanded it, they had done it."

When it comes to the holy, "as God commanded it" is the human equivalent of the Divine "it was very good". Chol is the space God makes for man. Kodesh is the space we make for God.

Wohl Legacy; Empowering Communities, Transforming Lives
With thanks to the Wohl Legacy for their generous sponsorship of Covenant & Conversation.
Maurice was a visionary philanthropist. Vivienne was a woman of the deepest humility.
Together, they were a unique partnership of dedication and grace, for whom living was giving.

More on Terumah

Building Builders

As soon as we read the opening lines of Terumah we begin the massive shift from the intense drama of the Exodus with its signs…

The Gift of Giving

It was the first Israelite house of worship, the first home Jews made for God. But the very idea is fraught with paradox, even contradiction.…

The Labour of Gratitude

There is an important principle in Judaism, a source of hope, and also one of the structuring principles of the Torah.

The Home We Build Together

The sequence of parsiyhot that begins with Terumah, and continues Tetzaveh, Ki Tissa, Vayakhel and Pekudei, is puzzling in many ways. First, it outlines the…

What Do We Receive When We Give?

The Lord spoke to Moses, saying, “Tell the Israelites to take an offering for Me; take My offering from all whose heart moves them to…

A Portable Home

The parsha of Terumah describes the construction of the Tabernacle, the first collective house of worship in the history of Israel. The first but not the…

Why We Value What We Make

The behavioural economist Dan Ariely did a series of experiments on what is known as the IKEA effect, or “why we overvalue what we make.”…

The Architecture of Holiness

From here to the end of the book of Exodus the Torah describes, in painstaking detail and great length, the construction of the Mishkan, the…

Tabernacle and Temple

This week’s sedra and those that follow it to the end of the book of Exodus, describe the great collective project of the Israelites in…

The Making Of An Ark

As I have stressed many times in these studies, the Torah was meant to be listened to, not read. The eye can scan many lines…